Do In God We Trust?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1af38/1af38f594f815065ca7405ab61bffccf9a992ec9" alt=""
Apparently NBC is holding a poll of whether we should remove "in God we trust" from our currency. The "yes, remove the motto" vote says "because it is a violation of separation of church and state"(that's a whole different blog topic - sheesh) and the "no, leave the motto on there" vote is because "it reflects our heritage and historic tradition."
I wasn't sure how to vote. Eventually, I voted "no", but I don't agree with the reasoning. Why did the vote only allow you to say "yes, remove the motto" because of a "violation of separation of church and state"? The reason I would vote yes is:
1. Let's be honest with ourselves: do we as a country still trust in God?
2. If so, what "god" do we trust in? We are so PC in this country, it's almost a crime to share your faith.
3. We do NOT represent that motto, and therefore don't deserve to have it on our currency.
I say take the motto off. The motto should read "in God Almighty we once trusted". As a nation, we have fallen FAR from our roots. Taking "in God we trust" off the currency doesn't mean those who still trust Him trust any less, it simply means we are finally being honest with ourselves as a nation.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4dae6/4dae639c78b5e03a11f2dd655e3b91e58252f8d8" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/08f98/08f980721742feb90d40eb22d26483d48bea1be6" alt=""
... but instead we panic.